JellyPages.com

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Blog post 5

In the story "Reason" by Isaac Asimov, robots are supposed to adhere to three rules, 1. robot may not harm a human, or through inaction allow a human to come to harm 2. A robot must obey orders given it by humans, except where such orders would violate the first law 3. A robot must protect its own existence, except where such action would violate laws 1 and 2. These rules were made to follow the idea that the humans would always be the masters of the robots, but what happens when they create a robot smart enough to make up his own master? Once that happens all these rules go down the drain. Once Cutie begins to believe that there is a higher power involved in all of this, humans become inferior beings. I thought it was cool that even though they had completely different beliefs, in the end they found out they could still work together despite those differences.
In "Super-Toys Last All Summer Long" by Brian Aldiss, the world has become massively overpopulated and restrictions have been placed on having children. The world is so distraught that nobody wants to have windows if all they're going to see is chaos. With the technology that has been created everyone is able to stay inside and enjoy gardens or cities without actually having to go outside. Not to mention that social interactions or relations with other humans are no longer necessary  because synthetic humans are being made so that they can ease the loneliness. The technology in this stories allows for human interactions to cease existing.  I found it really sad that David just wanted to be loved by his mother, like any child would, even though he was a synthetic life form. However, the mother couldn't love him because she knew he wasn't actually her son or even human.

8 comments:

  1. I also was amazed on how the robots and the humans both have two different beliefs but they still found a way to work together. I thought it was very depressing how David just wanted to be love by his only mother figure but she just didn't want him. At the end she just decided to give him back to the factory which isn't fair at all to him. She did try to love him but she just couldn't, just like you said, he wasn't even human.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also found it funny in story "Reason" they went through the trouble of trying to convince one another who is right or who is wrong. But despite their their belief they still did the same tasks that needed to be done efficiently.
    I was super sad in the story "Super-Toy Last All Summer Long." It broke my heart how how both of them wanted love but couldn't get it (mother wanted a real child. and Tommy wanting a real mother- a mother that'd love him). Ultimately, what broke my heart was when Tommy was cast aside at the end because Mummy now had the approval to have a child. That was crazy!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know! That second story was heartbreaking! and yeah the end of "Reason" actually reminded me a lot about humans. With all the different beliefs we have and despite the few people that constantly try to make others follow their own particular religion, most of us can work together, respect each other, and achieve our goals even if we don't believe in the same things.

      Delete
  3. I agree with your first point on "Reason" how despite everything they still managed to get the job done and not kill one another. And I also found the fact that little David just wanted to be loved by a mother really sad. And also really crazy that humans hardly even interact with each other anymore. It's sad to see the similarities between that story and today's society.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It most certainly is sad to see the similarities in that story and today. Going out with friends is almost pointless by now. Everyone's on their phone checking social media or messaging other people, someone only speaks once every 10 minutes. It's crazy.

      Delete
  4. I hadn't thought about the aspect you raise in "Reason" that they don't have to believe the same things in order to accomplish a common goal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was one of the coolest parts of the story for me. Reminded me of humans and how most of us can also reach common goals despite our different beliefs.

      Delete